Comments: Mar 21, 2013 - Karen BrownMy father (not 88) was an eagle scout in his youth. I would like to replace his award that was lost in a burglery a few years ago. Can you help me with this? He was from Barrien Springs Michigan when he was in the scouts and his mother was the camp's cook.
Mar 21, 2013 - Scouter PaulSep 30, 2013 - Rick MahlerI have gotten as far as life scout when I was in scouting now I am 48 years of age. Can a person my age still earn my eagle ranking. I also recieved my order of the arrow and would like to do my service hour. Is any of these things possible. Please let me know, I would like to finish these great archievements.
Sep 30, 2013 - Yukon Jack@ Rick. Adults (defined by boy scouting as 18+ years of age) cannot earn the Eagle Rank. They used to, back in the 1910s and until as late as 1968 I believe, but no longer. As for the OA, if you were voted in, tapped out, and finished your Ordeal as a youth, then you may indeed transfer your old lodge membership to your current council's lodge (unless you still live in your hometown and it is the same lodge...then just pay your dues and reactivate your membership) and pick up right here you left off. However, if you did not complete your Ordeal, the voting expires after 1 year and you must be re-selected and begin the process anew. Adults have a different nomination process from boys entirely, so let me know if you need to be re-elected. If you're not sure, I ask simply did you ever receive an OA sash? If you did, then you finished Ordeal at minimum and are good to go. Good luck.
Oct 24, 2013 - jason sageerim about to become an eagle scout next month. woohoo ill be the last eagle scout before my troop before we merge with another troop because our charter was pulled. :)
Jan 03, 2014 - Seth Parkinson I am currently a life scout. I am 14 and I plan on getting my Eagle before my birthday in April. I have no idea what to do for my project. I have some ideas but I really don't know for sure. Any ideas? Oh yeah, and my troop doesn't really do scouting any more and so I have pretty much done it all myself. I am also part of the OA.
Jan 05, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Seth - Yes, lots of ideas. Take a look at
Eagle Projects to see what others have done.
Mar 04, 2014 - Parent of an eager scoutI'm a little confused about the Eagle merit badge requirements. If a scout managed to earn extra merit badges such that he has more than the required 11 when achieving Life rank (for example, he's earned 16), does he still need to earn 10 additional merit badges while a Life scout or does total need to be 21 (i.e. he would only need to earn 5 more during that rank)as long as he's earned the Eagle required badges as well.
Mar 04, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Parent - It's a total of 21, so he'd need to earn 5 more. Your son can look over the Eagle application and notice it has spots for him to list all the merit badges he is using for Eagle.
Mar 06, 2014 - KarenHi. My son is a life scout. He has cognitive disabilities. I find discussion of the scouts with disabilities and achieving eagle rank with appropriate application, but I don't see discussion of how it pertains to the eagle project. By omission, it reads like they don't have to do one. Can you clarify?
Thank you.
Mar 07, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Karen - All eagle scouts do need to lead a service project. That is one of the rank requirements.
Mar 08, 2014 - KarenThank you. As there are accommodations made for merit badges, due to abilities, are there accommodations made for the Eagle project? The ability to plan, lead and execute are limited in these same boys. I don't see any guidelines, limits or suggestions pertaining to that aspect of attaining the rank. I am not able to find those details anywhere. Any ideas? Thanks for your help.
Mar 08, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Karen - I'm not sure what you would be looking for. There are no such guidelines, limits, or suggestions for any scout working towards his eagle rank. He needs to come up with a project idea as described in the Eagle Project Workbook, which has explanations and information for parents.
Since there are no minimum requirements for the project, except that the scout plan it and lead others, the scope and complexity of the project can vary greatly depending on the scout's abilities.
I would recommend you and your son discuss the expectations with his scoutmaster and district advancement chair since they will decide if a project is appropriate or not. They can also give you personal guidance on what planning and leadership they expect from the scout.
Mar 08, 2014 - KarenThank you. Did not have the impression that there are no minimum requirements. They seem more stringent than the merit badges. Will talk to them.
Mar 11, 2014 - Gene BairI am an Eagle Scout for 32 years now and am advising two Eagles Scouts on their Court of Honor ceremony. There is a discussion on whether or not they should have the patch already sown onto their uniforms for the ceremony. the packets have come back from National. I would say no patch until after the ceremony. The parents state they have seen videos of other ceremonies with the boy with the patch already on his uniform. I had my Life Scout badge still on my uniform when I received mine. I can not find any thing on the proper protocol. Thanks, GB.
Mar 11, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Gene - The ceremony is just to recognize the scout's accomplishments. It is nothing official, and is optional. If the scout has completed all the requirements and received the patch, there's no reason he can't be displaying it on his uniform.
Mar 12, 2014 - Bradley ShelledyScouter Paul, I agree, the scout should be proud of what they have accomplished and should have the right to wear the patch after it has been awarded to them, however I feel that just like they could not wear the other rank patches at the court of honor where in they received those ranks they should wear their life scout badges to their Eagle Scout court of honor just as they wore their previous ranks to the other courts of honor where in they received their other ranks.
Mar 12, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Bradley - The way courts of honor are run in your troop is not a BSA requirement, but the most common way. When a scout earns a rank, he could be presented his rank patch immediately after the board of review, or at the next patrol meeting, or next troop meeting, or pretty much any time. The presentation of the patch does not need to wait until a court of honor which may be months away.
There's an interesting post at
this page.
Mar 16, 2014 - Bradley ShelledyI guess I was lucky that my troop always had at least one board of review and court of honor per month so that each scout could be recognized not only before his peers but also before his families too. So when it came time for my Eagle Court of Honor I had a few friends that had gone before me.
Jun 19, 2014 - Jay MaplesI met all the requirements before my 18th birthday for Eagle except for the review board because I left the area. Is it possible to recover all the information and do the review board as an adult after several years.
I do not have my uniforms or records any longer and would need to recover them, is that possible also. I was tapped out and finished the ordeal for OA also and that is the only part of the uniform I have left.
Jun 20, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Jay - I doubt it. You could contact your former BSA council and ask them directly about recovering your records, and the possibility of having a board of review.
Jul 23, 2014 - Mom of Two ScoutsIs it mandatory for an Eagle candidate to have a recommendation/reference from a religious leader?
Is it mandatory to have one from an employer?
Jul 27, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Mom - No and no. If the scout is not affiliated with an organized religion, then the parent or guardian provides this reference. If the scout is not employed, then he obviously wouldn't have an employer.
Aug 23, 2014 - Mom of soon to be Eagle ScoutI have heard that beginning January 2015, earning your "Religious Emblem" will be a new requirement for Eagle. Is that true?
Aug 23, 2014 - Scouter Paul@Mom - No, it's not true. The Religious Emblem is a separate award from advancement.
Sep 09, 2014 - James AllenI am an adult Eagle Scout whose son has joined Cub Scouts as a Tiger Cub. Should I wear my uniform to his pack meetings even if I am not a member of the Pack leadership group?
Sep 09, 2014 - Scouter Paul@James - the BSA uniform is to be worn only by registered members of the BSA. You should submit a BSA adult application and become a member before wearing your uniform.
Nov 08, 2014 - Future Eagle Scout MomMy son has started to begin his eagle project. My son met with the troop committee chair to discuss some barriers that he is having with the eagle advisor in our troop. He has had trouble getting responses back to his emails. In the conversation, the chairperson stated that he has to have been in attendance of 75% of the troop meetings. First is that a requirement? My son is also in venturing crew and this summer he volunteered for both NYLT staffing (weekend/weeklong). Would that count as part of the time if the 75% a true requirement to earn his eagle? Also, can my son decide to leave the troop and complete his project with the crew? If so, what steps are needed to be done to do this?
Dec 19, 2014 - Ian StuartProjects aren't allowed to be fundraisers right?
Dec 19, 2014 - Scouter PaulA fundraiser is not an Eagle Service Project.
Dec 19, 2014 - Ian Stuart@Scouter Paul I didn't think it was but I was confused because on the Recent Eagle Scouts Projects page i found projects that appeared to be fundraisers, such as;
Raise $800 for toys for hospital in NE
Raise funds for church bell tower in WI
Raise funds for airplane crash memorial in KY
Aren't these projects fundraisers?
Dec 20, 2014 - Joe@Ian A Scout can raise funds for a project because let's face it, you can't do much for free. What makes the difference is where is that money going toward? You would not be able to raise money for the troop but you could raise money to help fund your project or donate it to a charity of some kind.
One Scout I know, raised money to help build a school in Peru and also collected donations for the kids attending the school.
Fund raising is not off limits but there are limitations.
Apr 21, 2015 - KenAt what age should boys get their Eagle? In our troop we have parents pushing their kids to get life and they just turned 13. they want their boys to have their Eagle by 14 years of age. That's to young for that rank to me.
Apr 22, 2015 - Scouter Paul@Ken - There's no minimum age requirement for earning Eagle. Whether a 13 year old Eagle seems too young to you, or me, or anyone else, doesn't matter a bit. By completing the stated requirements, he's earned the rank.
Jun 11, 2015 - Kelly Hart@Ken - Be careful passing judgement on these boys that are young. As long as they are
doing what is required then the achievement is well deserved. My oldest was told to put
on the breaks as he was super excited and inspired when he first joined. After being told
(several times) "you are too young and we are not an eagle factory", his charisma faded and
he felt as if he was doing something wrong. Even now at almost 16 he is being overlooked
again to be senior patrol leader because of his age and they spoke to him about it over 2
years ago. I thought he would be ok with it, but this has caused him to be even more
disheartened about scouts. So be careful on the fingers you point and worry about your
child! Scouts is an amazing experience and the requirements are not easy. So if your 13
year old is moving quickly and really embracing it -- go for it! He deserves it more than
the 17 year olds that are completing 10 merit badges in a month and doing a less than
adequate Eagle proje
Jul 25, 2015 - LeightonWe are attending an Eagle Scout ceremony for a friend
in another troop should my son (First Class rank) wear
his field uniform includin OA and merit badge sashes?
Jul 25, 2015 - Scouter Paul@Leighton - An Eagle ceremony is a great opportunity for
registered BSA members to wear their uniforms. Your son should
wear his merit badge sash, but not his Order of the Arrow sash.
He should only wear his OA sash if he is performing a function of
the OA. Also, he should never wear both the merit badge sash and
OA sash at the same time - it's one or the other draped over the
right shoulder to left hip, and neither one ever hung from the
belt.
Sep 23, 2015 - RonFor those of you with eager Scouts wanting to get their Eagle at a young age, encourage and
support them 100%. If someone in the Troop is slowing them down or discourage them, you need
to talk to the Scoutmaster or Committee Chair. There is no age requirement for Eagle. The most
important thing I stressed with the boys in my Troop was that they stayed active after earning their
Eagle because they owed it to the younger boys in the Troop to pay back what the older boys did
for them when they were new. One year, I took 64 Scouts to summer camp, and 9 of those were
active Eagle Scouts. We had 100% participation for camp that year.. We had boys earn their
Eagle at 13, and stay until they turned 18, when they registered as Assistant Scoutmasters. We
never used the term "Eagle Out" in our Troop. They could "age out" but we expected, and got, our
Eagles to stay active. They had a lot of input into the running the Troop and served as Instructors
and Junior Assistant Scoutmasters.
I
Nov 15, 2015 - Brendan SimonHi my name is Brendan I was not able to do a whole lot
in scouts because of where I lived and then I moved to
Idaho and was able to do some things but am 18 now
and would like to get my eagle what would I have to do?
Nov 16, 2015 - Scouter Paul@Brendan - If you are past your 18th birthday, you are past the
age of being a Boy Scout and earning your Eagle. An exception for
the age requirement is possible for scouts with disabilities.
Nov 17, 2015 - Scouter Joe@Brendan - As you may be passed the age to earn your Eagle Scout, you still have the opportunity to be a part of Venturing and earn the awards associated with that program like the Ranger Award and Venturing Summit Award.
You can be apart of a Venturing crew until your 21st birthday, giving you plenty of time to earn the awards and have fun in Scouting!
May 17, 2018 - Brian MorneaultOur house burned down and I lost all of my credentials for Eagle Scout. I reached out to my old Troop and they do not have any historical records. I am now 42 years of age and wanted to some direction to correct this. I am now serving as a Pack Committee Chair for my boys who are now involved with scouting. Any direction or assistance you can provide would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Brian
May 17, 2018 - Scouter Paul@Brian - 44 year old records can very well be a challenge to
recover due to ancient tech, merging councils, changing staff,
... but here's two things to try:
1. Contact the National BSA
Office - see
FAQ
page2. Contact the council of the community where you
earned your Eagle. Enter your zipcode at
this page to find local
council contact info.
If you just want to replace your patches,
pins, medals, ... then just purchasing those things off eBay is
an option, but they can be $$$$$.
Good Luck

Contest - Ask a Question - Add Content





This site is not officially associated with the Boy Scouts of America
Follow Me, Scouts
Recent Comments